Thanks Dave
Deanz
Normally--you would be totally correct! The issue with the HD speaker is they were so interested in making the speaker water resistant, the extra parts they added to achieve this, impede the speakers ability to move--like adding an extra pair of shocks to the ass end of a bike.
With the HD speaker--apply any bass, and the restriction of the extra parts is so much so, the speaker just craps out.
Again--you would normally be right--but in this case, the speaker itself is poorly designed for his application.
PEZ