The eyes are a big thing for me as well. Not so much color but what they are saying to me and do they make me melt!LOL Next most important thing is body language - how a man walks, stands, whatever- tells me alot about him and definately how he fits into those jeans! Wow!
Seems that what a woman looks for in a man can vary:
A study in Wisconsin showed that the kind of male face a woman finds attractive can differ - depending on where a woman is in her menstrual cycle.
For instance, if she is ovulating, she is attracted to men with rugged and masculine features.
If she is menstruating, she is more prone to be attracted to a man with scissors shoved in his temple and a bat jammed up his ass while he is on fire.