V-Rod vs Sportster 1200 : V-Twin Forum: Harley Davidson Forums

Evoking · 06-03-2008, 02:00 AM

Before you guys start flaming I understand these bikes are totally different. Nonetheless, I am looking for objective comparisons of the fun factor.

I used to ride an Aprilia RSV-R which is a 1000cc sportbike twin. I am now considering another bike and would like to stick with a twin but I may go the cruiser route. I have never ridden a Harley and can imagine that both are a blast in their own way.

I like the matte 08 Sportser 1200 for its simplistic, lean, Jimmy Dean feel. The Nightrod however has been tugging at me since I first saw its beefy lowslug stance. Any of you VRSC owners that have ridden a Sporty 1200 willing to offer feedback?

DLL66 · 06-03-2008, 08:02 PM

I used to have a 1994 1200 Sporty. The new ones are a bit different. Anyway, I have a bit more fun on my Night Rod. Don't get me wrong, a Sportser is also a fun bike, I just like the lowslug stance of my Night Rod. The difference between the Revolution and Evolution is quite a bit. The Night Rod definitely quicker in getting up to speed than the Sporty was.

DJW · 06-03-2008, 10:30 PM

Ride them both and see for yourself.

Then buy the v-rod.

(Yes, I've ridden both)

Wild Hog · 06-05-2008, 12:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evoking

Before you guys start flaming I understand these bikes are totally different. Nonetheless, I am looking for objective comparisons of the fun factor.

I used to ride an Aprilia RSV-R which is a 1000cc sportbike twin. I am now considering another bike and would like to stick with a twin but I may go the cruiser route. I have never ridden a Harley and can imagine that both are a blast in their own way.

I like the matte 08 Sportser 1200 for its simplistic, lean, Jimmy Dean feel. The Nightrod however has been tugging at me since I first saw its beefy lowslug stance. Any of you VRSC owners that have ridden a Sporty 1200 willing to offer feedback?

Used to own a 06 VRSCA and the bike screams. Now riding a Dyna but you are comparing apples to oranges so my advice is to ride both. My guess is that if you are coming off a sportbike you are going to like the V-Rod but the new sportsters are nice bikes as well. Good luck.

mattsnever · 06-07-2008, 09:01 AM

I like both i have an '06 Low Sporty and its nice for longer irdes. My VRSCD is kick a** for rididng around town and shorter trips.. just depends on what you what to use the bike for...

Carrie · 06-07-2008, 10:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DJW

Ride them both and see for yourself.

Then buy the v-rod.

(Yes, I've ridden both)

mtkawboy · 06-07-2008, 11:04 AM

Harleys dont have water in them, buy a Hayabusa if you want water & to haul ass. Not to mention V-rods are ugly as #ell

Carrie · 06-07-2008, 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mtkawboy

Harleys dont have water in them, buy a Hayabusa if you want water & to haul ass. Not to mention V-rods are ugly as #ell

In the eye of the beholder.

Carrie · 06-07-2008, 12:17 PM

Hey Evoking! Keep your eye on the Night Rod Special! Bad ass bike there!

triple buzz · 06-08-2008, 10:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mtkawboy

Harleys dont have water in them, buy a Hayabusa if you want water & to haul ass. Not to mention V-rods are ugly as #ell

An educated reply from a guy that rides a fat boy.You never see them around. BTW you spelled Harley wrong in your profile.

triple buzz · 06-08-2008, 10:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evoking

Before you guys start flaming I understand these bikes are totally different. Nonetheless, I am looking for objective comparisons of the fun factor.

I used to ride an Aprilia RSV-R which is a 1000cc sportbike twin. I am now considering another bike and would like to stick with a twin but I may go the cruiser route. I have never ridden a Harley and can imagine that both are a blast in their own way.

I like the matte 08 Sportser 1200 for its simplistic, lean, Jimmy Dean feel. The Nightrod however has been tugging at me since I first saw its beefy lowslug stance. Any of you VRSC owners that have ridden a Sporty 1200 willing to offer feedback?

Try them both. I have a rod, and I don't dislike sporty's but being a fellow sport biker, I can tell you that the v-rod will make you smile more. I sure it's a bias opinion , but a test ride will answer your question. The best sporty Harley has isn't available here in the USA. The XR 1200 looks bad ass, and handles. Got to love the MoCo.

Evoking · 06-12-2008, 01:32 AM

I ended up getting a new NightTrain. It is stage 1, lowered, rear disc wheel, skull grips, mirrors, pegs. I'll likely switch out the skull theme for a more simple look.

Only thing I may change is an aftermarket front wheel. Any suggestions on good sources?

here are some pics:

Lt James · 06-12-2008, 08:47 AM

Sweet Ride Evoking!! Great choice, congrats!

oh1deuce · 06-12-2008, 09:13 AM

Sharp Train Evoking!!!

Hogpro will take care of you on anything wheel related. They helped me get a PM wheel shipped from PM in a few days when everyone else told me 4 to 5 and 6 to 8 weeks.

ei5fk · 06-12-2008, 04:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evoking

Any of you VRSC owners that have ridden a Sporty 1200 willing to offer feedback?

Have the VRSCDX a year, drove the Nightster last weekend, have driven the Crossbones a few times and have one on order, in my opinion its a far nicer bike to drive than the DX & Nightster, try one before you make up your mind, the Bones holds the road better than the Nightster and though its a good bit heavier than the Night Rod Special it feels a whole lot lighter, warning, front brake in the Bones not great, good luck with your choice